BattleBlock Theater is the Behemoth's third game. It has its own wiki, the BattleBlock Theater Wiki. This game unlocks the Can't Stop Crying Pack DLC, and it follows the adventures of Hatty Hattington and his friends.
The game begins with the player character and his friend Hatty Hattington becoming shipwrecked on a mysterious, seemingly abandoned island. However, upon investigation, the island is revealed to be inhabited by technologically advanced cats. The cats, who force their prisoners into deadly theater performances, watch with amusement as the player fights for his survival. Hatty, meanwhile, is given a strange top hat. Appearing to be possessed by the hat's unknown powers, Hatty begins working for the cats and against the player. At the end of the game, after Hatty is saved from the cats and the hat's possession, he is unable to move or do anything. He is presumed dead and entitled a vegetable by the narrator, and the game ends with Hatty at the bottom of the ocean, possibly being revived or being once again possessed by the hat's powers.
In the game BattleBlock Theater, players control a prisoner as they are forced to play through games. It is also unknown who made the arena. Controls are simple, with the game largely consisting of running, jumping and punching. Levels are made up of various types of blocks, such as collapsing blocks, sticky walls, bouncy volcanic rocks and deadly spikes, and also feature hazards such as water and deadly creatures.
The main mode in the game is Adventure Mode, which can be played solo or co-operatively with a second player. During co-operative play, players are able to work together to overcome obstacles, which includes throwing eachother across gaps, using their heads as platforms and helping each other up ledges, although there is just as much opportunity to sabotage your partner. Adventure mode consists of various worlds each with a set of levels. In order to progress to the next world, players need to collect gems which can also be used to unlock prisoners, which allows you to change your head. Players can also collect balls of yarn which they lol
Arena mode is a competitive mode for up to four players, which can be played free-for-all or in teams. There are several match types including:
- Soul: Steal enemy soul and run away. Capture and hold the enemy's souls to gain points. Kill a soul-carrier to release their souls to roam the level.
- Muckle: Beat and kill the enemy team to earn your team points.
- Challenge: Score the best time on a given level.
- King Of The Hill: Stand on the crown blocks to gain your team points.
- Color The World: Color more blocks than the other team.
- Grab The Gold: Grab more gold from the golden whale than the other team and deposit it in the floating safe to score points for your team
- Ball Game: Get the ball in the basket.
- Horse: Ride the opposing team's horse to your stables to gain points for your team.
The game also features a Level Editor, which allows players to create their own stages for any game type. These levels can be assembled into a playlist, consisting of various Adventure and Arena levels, and uploaded to the community for others to download. There is also additional content unlocked for players who also own Castle Crashers and Alien Hominid HD.